URBAN RE//COGNITION

Human civilization is turning into a global network of cities: urbanization and globalization are the two key trends of development. People are agents within this network, animating it with their activities. The form of activity, which is the real heartbeat of this network, is the migration: people all over the world move from the rural areas to the cities and further between the cities, seeking the upgrade of their lifestyle, and cities, in turn, compete to attract people. The attractiveness, therefore, is one of the key features to be used for the estimation of a certain city’s success.

This paper contains the review of the design method suggested within the studio project at IAAC by a group of students on the MACAD program.

LIKENESS AND IMAGE

Mimicry is one of the key evolution inventions used by many species. Humans don’t have disruptive coloration, they can’t mimic other species to cheat their enemies but they have mastered another much more powerful means of mimicry: learning. The ability to copy and repeat successful life scenarios is one of the key factors of human victory in natural selection. The very evolutionary success of primates and homo sapiens in particular is based on the exceptional ability to learn quickly by following the example, copying the behaviour and the way of doing of the more experienced fellows. It is quite natural, therefore, that the practices of reproduction and re-application of successful scenarios are widely spread throughout most of the cultures worldwide. The intercultural exchange is the extension of this practice: people rapidly accept alien habits which they find attractive, the urban lifestyles being no exclusion.

Mimicry is the foundation of style. Likeness is one of the fundamental cultural factors, the key media of transferring knowledge in generations. Over several thousand years of urban history humanity has practiced many ways of encoding ideas into built forms. The review of the ancient semantic reproduction practices reveal interesting overlaps with the modern machine learning algorithms. The concept of likeness was very important for the monotheistic cultures of Europe and Near East in the middle ages for God has created man in his own image and likeness. This had a great effect on the entire visual culture, including architecture: in fact, all significant buildings had to be built according to the certain iconographic program, so that they would be the representation of some hierarchically high prototype – Holy Sepulchre, Hagia Sophia or the mystic Heavenly Jerusalem. It is important that simply naming the new object after the prototype was very often sufficient to create likeness, in spite of total visual mismatch between the model and its “copy”. In other cases the numerical matching of the dimensions was important while the details didn’t matter.

These practices of transferring the meaning without actually transferring the image – or transferring it only partially – amazingly resemble the modern semantic and  image-based ML algorithms and their results. Actually, the visualization of the unseen and the translation between the verbal and the visual have always been the key artistic task and exploring the artistic potential of the generative AI technologies seems extremely exciting.

PROJECT

Studio project covered in this paper was developed over three months of the Artificial Intelligence in Architecture module of MACAD program. The objective was to create a method of analyzing a public space and transferring its features to another location.

In order to narrow down the field of research we decided to focus on only one type of public space, namely the squares. We have selected a number of squares in Spain (located in Madrid, Barcelona, Bilbao and Granada) and a few more in Paris and London.

The method is based on a few assumptions:

  1. The successful social scenarios are related to the formal characteristics of a public space.
  2. The importance of certain features can be estimated through the analysis of social media, in addition to conventional social surveying methods.
  3. Those characteristics can be parametrized and replicated.
  4. Complex analysis of those features and their assessment can be performed by using the ML technologies and an optimal public space can be further predicted by the neural network trained to recognize features of attractiveness.

WORKFLOW

The first assumption is driving a connection between the formal qualities of the space and its attractiveness for the social activities. In order to formalize the assessment we have selected a number of urban features: benches, fountains, vegetation, hard surface, water etc. We have further masked them out on fragments of satellite images of the chosen squares and run the semantic segmentation training of the model.

In parallel we ran the NLP analysis. We created a dataset of 50 squares with distinctive features using google API. We selected as many latest comments as we could find for the last 2 years to attain less discrepancy in the data. Around 250-300 reviews for each square were collected manually. The NLP method that we used included 2 main analysis: sentiment and topic modeling. We ran it in 10 steps to ensure correct format of textual data to identify popular and unpopular scenarios:

01: COLLECTION OF DATASET

02: DATA TOKENIZING

03: STOPWORDS REMOVAL

04: STEMMING

05: LEMMATIZATION

06: COUNT VECTORIZATION

07: EDA

08: WORD CLOUD

09: SENTIMENT ANALYSIS

10: TOPIC MODELING

We ran the polarity/subjectivity analysis for each square to get the overall popularity scores. This method still needed to be refined in order to extract meaningful data that could be related to the features of the image segmentation. Hence we trained a LDA model to get coherence values for the number of topics in the data and identified the most popular words in each topic. The PCA analysis showed us which are the most distinctive topics from the dataset and we could extract 5 main categories from the data based on PCA. This was the first part of the analysis , in order to link this data to the features of the image segmentation , we identified the frequency of each popular words in each topic and assigned a value between 0 to 1 based on token values that we got from the PCA analysis. Below are the 14 categories of image segmentation that are relatable to the 5 categories of NLP.

Once we had the results of the NLP analysis, which gave us the public assessment of squares and particular urban features, we did the space syntax visual graph analysis (VGA) in order to get the values for a few key spatial qualities: visibility, connectivity and compactness.

CONCLUSION

We believe that the result of our quick research proves that the attractiveness of a public space is a measurable category. Yet, we regard our methodological experiment as the very beginning of a long path to be walked. The workflow we have created is in no way a substitute to the conventional surveying, analysis, briefing and design workflow but rather an addition to it. Social media is a huge source of data. Their key advantage is that they contain unmoderated collective expression and provide, therefore, a valuable addition to the data collected by the conventional means of surveying. However, one must be careful using them because they represent a certain strata of the population and data collected from social media must not be taken as fully coherent and complete. At the same time, social media aid representation of some groups within the population who have not been given voice before. Be it as it may, social media must not be neglected as an important source of data, although have to be examined critically and carefully.

Another important reason why the suggested method is valid is the very nature of the analyzed data. Nowadays the entire initial phase of the design workflow has changed completely: previously the design was driven equally by the designers knowledge and sense, while now we are often designing without even visiting the site. Basing the design on the information from the internet has somewhat become a professional standard. Google street views seem to suffice and EPW-based simulation substitutes breathing the air of the future building or urban area. Since everything on the internet is digital data, it is totally appropriate to incorporate the data science tools into the design practice. Once again the design becomes a reflection of an image.

Progressive city administrations throughout the world are keen to make their cities attractive and invest a lot in upgrading the urban environment. We have attempted to create an analytical and design tool to facilitate the process of recognizing and transferring the successful urban scenarios. However, so far we have mostly concentrated on the analytical outcome of the AI application, while the design tool is still to be developed. There are a few directions for further experimenting: style GANs can be used to create an automated tool which will be adding certain formal qualities to the design. It can work in different ways: contextualize the design proposal or, on the contrary, translate it into the formal language of the prototype. Alternatively, a context reader can be created, which would generate surface textures for the urban interventions based on the context images interpolated in latent space. 2D-to-3D algorithms can be used to generate geometry from the raster patterns of the satellite or context photography etc.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 

  1. Notes on the synthesis of form

Christopher Alexander

  1. Perception and computer vision

Markus Vincze, Sven Wachsmuth, and Gerhard Sagerer

  1. The second digital turn

Mario Carpo

  1. Programming After Program

Kazys Varnelis

  1. AI Aesthetics

           Lev Manovich

  1. The Incongruous Figure

Rachael McCall

  1. Suggestive drawing among human and artificial intelligence

Nono Martínez Alonso

  1. Towards Hallucinating Machines – Designing with Computational Vision

Matias del Campo, Alexandra Carlson, Sandra Manninger

  1. Drawing with Bots: Human-computer Collaborative Drawing Experiments

Hao Zheng

  1. Intensive Science and Virtual Philosophy

Manuel DeLanda

 

IAAC MACAD AIA Group 01

Students:

Sachin Dabas

Yara Gadah

Pedro Ribeiro

Sergey Kryuchkov

 

Faculty:

Angelos Chronis – lead studio mentor

Lea Khairallah – studio assistant

Theory:

Zeynep Aksöz

Mark Balzar